Sometimes I feel like the love child of Rodney Dangerfield and the Rolling Stones - not only can I get no respect, I can't get no satisfaction.
I recently had a very disheartening conversation - after a long, tough week - that, instead of helping me resolve some of the issues I've been having within the fire department only succeeded in bringing my feelings of disgust and disillusionment to all new levels. There were a lot of things that were said that were disheartening, disappointing, and downright ill conceived and better left unsaid - but like in every worldview-changing conversation, there was what I like to call a Defining Moment. The defining moment last night was when one of the senior officers in our department, a man with decades of service under his belt, looked me in the eye and told me that he felt I should be a "kinder, gentler, nicer person."
Huh. Let's take a look at what that means. (Definitions provided by my favorite book ever - Merriam Webster's dictionary at www.m-w.com)
Kinder - of a sympathetic or helpful nature. I don't have much sympathy, but I have plenty of empathy, and I've never failed to offer help or refused those who ask. Ever.
Gentler - free from harshness, sternness, or violence. You've kind of got me there. I may at times be construed as harsh, as I don't believe in prevarication or artifice, but I would never consider myself to be stern, or particularly violent with anything other than my vocabulary.
Nicer - showing fastidious or finicky tastes : particular : exacting in requirements or standards. Interesting that this definition comes before the ones that imply docility or virtue. I think that I am VERY exacting in my requirements and standards, and particularly fastidious in most things I do.
So, after I thought about it for a while, and failed to see how I lacked any of these qualities, I decided that what he must have meant is that he wants me to be more OBEDIENT. Interestingly enough, if you look obedient up in a thesaurus, this is what you get:
amenable, compliant, conformable, docile, acquiescent, agreeable, amiable, obliging, decorous, disciplined, mannerly, controllable, governable, manageable, gentle, meek, mild
Yeah, I'm pretty sure he meant obedient. Who likes someone who points out your flaws, even when it's meant to help you grow?
{A side note for those just tuning in... that conversation pissed me off in the most incredible way - AND I AM STILL ANGRY.}
When did we become a people so focused on façade that we failed to see beneath the surface? I don't think that anyone should be a jerk just for the sake of being a jerk, but when did we become so shallow that a person's value is completely dependent on how they are perceived, instead of on who they are and what they do? I may be barking up the completely wrong tree, and my people-value priorities may be completely fucked up, but I will judge you on the quality of your soul, not the prettiness of your paper wrapping.
After all, Ted Bundy was an awfully charming guy.
Always had a friendly word for people.
Described as a "very nice man" by most of the people he came in contact with.
He killed and raped 35 women and played sexual games with their corpses.
I'm so tired of people epitomizing "nice". Nice is overrated. Nice is overvalued. Nice is how they describe the Stepford Wives. Nice doesn't get things done.
Don't just take my word for it - here's a small excerpt from a book called Don't be Nice, Be Real by Kelly Bryson. Check it out:
The Price of Nice
Here are just a few of the costs:
1. Always being nice prevents people around you from receiving congruent feedback that would stimulate their growth. (By growth I mean gaining knowledge of oneself and others.)
2. "Nice" people often react with pain if anyone around them expresses uncomfortable feelings. They get angry, thinking others should have to be nice too. Or they feel hurt and confused if someone does not appreciate their niceness. Others often sense this and avoid giving them congruent feedback thereby effectively blocking the nice person’s emotional growth.
3. With “nice” people you never know where you really stand. The nice person allows others to accidentally oppress them. The “nice” person might be resenting you just for talking to them, because really they are needing to pee. But instead of saying so, they stand there nodding and smiling, with legs tightly crossed, pretending to listen (lights are on but nobody’s home).
4. You never know with a nice person if the relationship would survive a conflict or angry confrontation. This uncertainty of course greatly limits the depths of intimacy possible.
5. Do you really trust a “nice” person to back you up if confrontation were really needed?
6. Often people in relationship with nice people turn their irritation toward themselves because it is so confusing how they could be so upset with someone so “nice.” In intimate relationships this leads to guilt, self hate and depression.
7. “Nice” people frequently keep all the anger in until they find a safe place to dump it, i.e., a child, a federal building to blow up, a helpless dependent mate. (Timothy McVeigh, the suspect in the Oklahoma City bombing is described by acquaintances as a very, very nice guy, who would give you the shirt off his back.) Success in keeping the anger in will often manifest as psychosomatic illnesses (ulcers, back problems, heart disease, etc.).
So, really, it's important that I be NICER?
I'll tell you what - I'm not malicious, I'm not spiteful, I'm not mean. I tell it like I see it, and I don't ever say anything just to be hurtful - I try and ensure that everything I say has a purpose. I go out of my way to help those that need it, and I don't judge people - ever. I'm definitely not the "nicest" person on the block - I've got a reputation for saying things that people don't want to hear - even if they need to. I've found, however, that denying ugliness exists doesn't ever make it go away, and most of the time the longer something is ignored, the uglier it grows. I prefer to nip it in the bud- I'm much better equipped to deal with a snowball than an avalanche.
Sure, I can work on being more user friendly. Sure, I can work on trying to clean up my language. We all can use improvement - and that's a good thing, I think. If everybody was perfect, I can't imagine that the world would be very interesting.
But to the officer that missed all of my good points and made me feel like a jerk - I'll work on being nicer. You work on learning how to be a leader and how to talk to people constructively. Hopefully one day we'll both be able to meet in the middle and acknowledge each other's strengths. Failing that, maybe we'll just agree to disagree.