One of the things that I find hardest to deal with is the lack of animal stewardship in many countries. Living in America for most of my life has given me a sense of entitlement to the many human rights I am afforded, and set my standards very high when it comes to the care and stewardship of animals. I forget, sometimes, that it’s different elsewhere, and I forget how privileged we are in the States.
Many times in my travels I have seen animals exploited in tourist shows, used for profit or for their labor, and some just flat out abused for no particular gain. The concept of “pet” is intrinsically American, I think, and we spoil our pets – spending on their care and wellbeing what people in other countries would like to be able to spend on their children.
There are exceptions, of course – the whale watching tour that I went out on a few days ago had staff that were exceptional in their care for the animals and the environment, and I’m looking forward to going out with them again on Friday. There are also horrific abuse and exploitation cases that happen in the US, although all are illegal and accompanied by heavy penalties.
Mexico has come a long way since I first visited over 20 years ago, but I still see things that leave me appalled. There is a bullring here in Puerto Vallarta that has incredible lines outside when it is open – many tourists find out the hard way that the bull always loses, and sometimes 4 or 5 bulls will die in a day.
There are other examples of the lower standards of animal care, but the ones that I find most tragic are those that are subtle enough to evoke pity, but not egregious enough to invoke outrage. Those are the animals that suffer the longest, the ones that people shake their heads over, the ones that usually live months in captivity before dying and quickly being replaced.
I saw a bird show today, at the resort. I’m staying at a Westin property – a big name, with hotels all over the world. I believe that the majority interest in the Westin group is American, which makes today even more shameful. I went to check on Mom by the pool, and was coming back from an errand to get her tangerines when I heard birds screeching. (My grandmother had large birds for many years, and once you hear a three foot bird scream, you don’t ever forget it. I was actually surprised that the birds at the Westin could only say “Hola”…my grandmother’s African Grays hardly ever shut up.)
I walked over to see four large birds on metal perches near the pools, with two trainers.
They were beautiful birds at first glance, and quite calm given the large crowd by the pool. I was able to use the macro function on my camera within a foot of several of the birds, and not once did they attempt to bite me. (Did I mention how smart they are? PS - he is eating a peanut, but totally pretending that it is my head. The evil lurking in his eyes gives it away.)
I stopped to watch for a few minutes, and I noted that the birds were in somewhat ragged condition. Most were nothing obvious – ragged pinions, missing feathers, broken or twisted beaks.
One poor bird, a beautiful peach color, was so nervous and sick many of his feathers were gone. He repeatedly tried to fly off his perch, but since his wings were clipped, he would fall. He also could not be coaxed to perform many of his tricks, and was just in general lethargic. My heart hurt for the poor thing.
I will say that the trainers seemed to care for the birds, praising them generously, protecting them from the crowd, and not pushing the birds to perform past what they were willing to do, but the condition of the birds themselves concerned me. Especially when the trainers said they were raising money for the conservation of birds! I don’t know if these birds were rescues, if they were raised in captivity, or if they were purchased, but what I do know is that I am disappointed in the Westin for allowing the show without ensuring that the animals are being cared for appropriately.
It’s too easy, I think, for large companies to perform to the standards set without maintaining their own. A Westin property in the States would not be able to get away with having animals in that condition in a show, whether or not it’s free – the people at PETA would be picketing their doorstep in seconds. But here, in Mexico, the standards are not yet so high, and so they don’t hold to the standards set on their properties in the US – a shame, in my opinion. Then again, I’ve been told that I expect too much, that I hold to standards too high that are difficult to meet. But really, if we don’t set our standards high, what can we ever hope to achieve other than mediocrity?